> And yet you love passkeys?
Yes. The security benefit can't be overstated.
> How much will you love them when you're locked out of something you can't do without?
I certainly wouldn't be happy if this did happen, but it would be my stupidity (or the stupidity of those who implemented it on the service/platform where the problem occurred) which I would blame more than the fault of the tool. I do keep all passkeys in Bitwarden now so that's something at least.
> The security benefit can't be overstated.
Security benefit appears strongly overstated. Compared to using a password manager (including generated secure passwords for each account), there isn't a significant security benefit. passkeys require using a manager as well, so there isn't much point.
> ...but it would be my stupidity...
All people are stupid sometimes. A security flow that doesn't account for this very well isn't a very good security flow.
(Related: everyone tends to be unlucky eventually, and, unfortunately, everyone becomes incapacitated/dies eventually. Security flows need to account for these as well. Not to mention that in my experience, no software company continues to offer a quality service at a reasonable price forever. You're lucky to get 10 years. Having access to my accounts tied to a single piece of software is likely to become a big pain at some point.)
> passkeys require using a manager as well, so there isn't much point.
No they don't. I use hardware passkeys for all my important accounts. It's extremely easy.
I think this is probably one of the reasons people have very different passkey experiences. Hardware passkeys are great and software ones appear to be less great.