If the spec was only arguing that avoiding flags allowed for simpler implementation of minimal in-order pipelines... I might actually agree with it.

But the argument in the spec explicitly uses the "added complexity to out-of-order microarchitectures" as a part of the justification for not having conditional move (and flags). It's the most commonly parroted part of the argument (see above) and the part of the argument I'm responding to.

I actually agree with much of the spec's argument. The cost of not having flags is pretty low, the MIPS approach does work pretty well, and it does simply things.

I'm just not sure it was the right trade off, and I strongly disagree with its attempt to use OoO cores as part of the justification.