My own thoughts on this, with examples https://github.com/nfcampos/loop-dev/blob/main/README.md
Are those your own thoughts? Or Claude's? I tried to read but had to stop a few paragraphs in because of Claude's annoying authorial voice.
No, they really are my thoughts, I've been doing this stuff pretty much every day for the past 6 months
No offense, but this sentiment is diluted by commits like this:
https://github.com/nfcampos/loop-dev/commit/e28b1fce0078e605...
I assume that GP was just saying that they would prefer to read these thoughts written by a human author (preferably you). I agree.
That commit happens to be a find replace because i usually write for my company’s blog (we)
I would be more willing to believe you only used Claude for minor editing tasks if you disclosed your usage of Claude upfront.
This commit seems to mostly be grammar fixes? If someone used a spell/grammar checker it might produce a diff similar to this. Why does the fact it was Claude and not Microsoft Word or other matter in this case?
Because Microsoft Word doesn't write blog posts for you
Edit: I just realized that Microsoft Word probably does do that now, and I hate it.
Copilot is the new clippy meme. Copilot is hiding in every MS product and is ready to write an email for you, anytime.
Yes but that commit doesn't support the fact that it has written it for the user.
That's a perfect use case for an LLM: grammar-aware find and replace (spicy find and replace.)
Are those your own thoughts? Or Claude's? I tried to read but had to stop a few paragraphs in because of Claude's annoying authorial voice.
No, they really are my thoughts, I've been doing this stuff pretty much every day for the past 6 months
No offense, but this sentiment is diluted by commits like this:
https://github.com/nfcampos/loop-dev/commit/e28b1fce0078e605...
I assume that GP was just saying that they would prefer to read these thoughts written by a human author (preferably you). I agree.
That commit happens to be a find replace because i usually write for my company’s blog (we)
I would be more willing to believe you only used Claude for minor editing tasks if you disclosed your usage of Claude upfront.
This commit seems to mostly be grammar fixes? If someone used a spell/grammar checker it might produce a diff similar to this. Why does the fact it was Claude and not Microsoft Word or other matter in this case?
Because Microsoft Word doesn't write blog posts for you
Edit: I just realized that Microsoft Word probably does do that now, and I hate it.
Copilot is the new clippy meme. Copilot is hiding in every MS product and is ready to write an email for you, anytime.
Yes but that commit doesn't support the fact that it has written it for the user.
That's a perfect use case for an LLM: grammar-aware find and replace (spicy find and replace.)