I think the risks of a rewrite - especially when using AI - are far more problematic than memory safety. In the long run those C projects will be memory safe in the next five years using memory safe C implementations.
I think the risks of a rewrite - especially when using AI - are far more problematic than memory safety. In the long run those C projects will be memory safe in the next five years using memory safe C implementations.
My perspective is that it is good to have a beta in a lot of directions.
No one really knows what the endgame of software security looks like.
So some people should try the port to rust angle, some should focus on hardening the C, some should explore more exotic options like formally provable languages etc
There is nothing wrong with trying different things. But the fundamental problem here is that projects and their communities are social projects and need to be to fulfill their purposes and to ensure long term maintenance. In a free software context, rewrites just like forks (1) are fundamentally an asocial (2) activity because they fragment the community (if successful) and then increase overall maintenance burden if not able to replace the original project completely (rarely the case). Disrespect the license choice of the original authors makes this worse.
1) There may be situation were are fork makes sense (e.g. because one project can not serve different use cases well): 2) Which is why usually a "higher goal" is used to justify this, e.g. authors pretend (or lie to themselves, or may be be stupid enough to actually believe this) that some improvement in memory safety is really that important.
You won't get anywhere pressing your case here. This group has already found you guilty, and no argument will change their minds.
You've been caricatured into a blind AI-follower rust-rewriter-just-because type, and that's the surface they'll continually attack (you're wasting time, hurting the community, v2-itis, bikeshedding, premature optimization, copyright violation, moustache-twirling-evil-intent-rug-pull-later, etc etc etc).
Just continue in your work. It's good, and we need people like you.