Not if the two things you want are "solar power for your home" and "for your roof to not be covered in obvious solar panels".

I have a Tesla solar roof. I bought it knowing there were cheaper options for equivalent solar power because I liked the aesthetics.

Does it actually make sense financially vs investing in something else?

No it doesn’t, but style never makes financial sense.

The Bottega Veneta of roof tiles.

Not really, no.

But I guess my first question is why you want solar panels at all then? For most people it’s about saving money long term first, then maybe energy independence (especially in emergencies) if possible, then just wanting to go green. If it’s aesthetics, you can do a cool roof without solar I assume.

What drove you to get solar panels ultimately and why did you go Tesla? Genuinely curious. I have a feeling you’ll say something i hadn’t considered.

No, you're pretty spot on. It was the overlap of a couple of factors:

1. I wanted solar & batteries as a buffer for grid outages

2. I wanted to be able to offset some of my energy usage with solar

3. I wanted my roof to look nice, and personally I think solar panels strapped onto a roof don't look very appealing.

4. At the time, Tesla was one of the few names in town for an integrated solar roof.

Saving money wasn't really part of the calculus, which worked out because as the article and parallel comments note, getting a Tesla solar roof is a pretty bad decision if one of your primary factors is cost or saving money on your electric bill.