Hmmm, given the general mood in this case, I feel like there's a lot of people keen to find any criticism of the code they can and amplify it as possible. Most of it strikes me as relatively shallow at the moment, though (that is, apart from the fact that merging such a large LLM assisted port is certainly a, uh _bold_ move (to put it lightly), there's not much that people are pointing out about the actual result that feels like it's worse than any other port in progress, but there is definitely a lot of hay being made about any issue that is found).
> Most of it strikes me as relatively shallow at the moment
It is. We’re what, a week into this exercise? Absolutely everyone criticizing it, with no exceptions, is behaving like a micromanaging middle manager who couldn’t even dream of doing the work themselves.
I half want to start a list of “people to ignore”, but such people tend to expose themselves in every other comment anyway.
Idk the pr author did merge it into main and talked about writing a blog post. To me that sounds like the author felt it was ready for public critique and feedback, especially for software with a fair bit of users
It may just be different expectations about what the `main` branch means. In my organization we don't merge half-finished work into `main`.
[flagged]
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
> Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills.
I did not say that HN is turning into reddit nor indicate any view on any way in which HN is trending. Remarking that Reddit and HN are similar is not rule breaking, they are both vote systems, etc.