In 2023 exactly two Uber passengers died in NYC. One from jumping out of their moving vehicle onto the LIE and the other from being rear-ended by a drag racer on the Whitestone Expressway.
The alternative to taking the subway for the vast majority of NYC residents is not driving to work.
And as an Uber passenger living in NYC I overwhelmingly spent my time on roads that were not highways.
I can't find exact taxi passenger deaths but between 2019 & 2023 there were 23 passenger fatalities across all rideshare services and taxis. At least one of those was a fatal drug overdose (2022).
> between 2019 & 2023 there were 23 passenger fatalities across all rideshare services and taxis
Which is way more than the total number of homicides on the subway system. All of this is before adjusting for trip frequency. (Uber and Lyft do about a fifth of the trips as the subway.)
I lived in New York for 10 years and go back frequently. I take Ubers and cabs (and Blade) all the time. It's convenient. And sometimes, yes, I just want a quiet space in which to relax. But pretending it's safer is simply untrue.
Wait we went from simple assault to comparing it just to homicides now? I just don't want to get attacked or slashed by somebody.
Okay you lived in NY for 10 years, I lived there for over 40. The subway is shit compared to where it was only a handful of years ago. In the last years that I was there, Uber was way safer.
Also I said "fatalities", which isn't just murder and isn't even necessarily a crime. There were 39 homicides in the subway[1] during that same period. So it's not less. But also those are murders whereas the 23 were mostly from accidents.
[1]: 2019: 3, 2020: 6, 2021: 8, 2022: 7, 2023: 5, 2024: 10 (source: compstat).