Independently replicated. Reviewed says pretty much nothing.
Peer review is a sniff test. It cannot guarantee that the results are correct and the conclusions are right. It is just designed to limit some kinds of errors. Replication is important.
Case studies can't be replicated. They aren't experiments.
you can find multiple cases that are comparable. one case study is an anecdote. multiple studies for the same kind of case...
Tough to replicate an isolated case study?
Especially if they are made up.
Peer review is a sniff test. It cannot guarantee that the results are correct and the conclusions are right. It is just designed to limit some kinds of errors. Replication is important.
Case studies can't be replicated. They aren't experiments.
you can find multiple cases that are comparable. one case study is an anecdote. multiple studies for the same kind of case...
Tough to replicate an isolated case study?
Especially if they are made up.