The framing of "Is Show HN dead?" misses something fundamental. Show HN was never a separate product. It's just a tag on the same ranking algorithm that handles everything else. Stories rise and fall by the same gravity formula, and Show HN posts compete directly with major tech news, drama, and viral essays.

I've launched multiple side projects through Show HN over the years. The ones that got traction weren't better products. They hit the front page during a slow news hour and got enough early upvotes to survive the ranking curve. The ones that flopped were arguably more interesting but landed during a busy cycle. That's not a Show HN problem, that's a single-ranking-pool problem.

What would actually help is a separate ranking pool for Show HN with slower time decay. Let projects sit visible for longer so the community can actually try them before they drop off. pg's original vision was about making things people want. Hard to evaluate that in a 90-minute window.