I'm old, so I remember when Skyrim came out. At the time, people were howling about how "dumbed down" the RPG had become compared to previous versions. They had simplified so many systems. Seemed to work out for them overall.

I understand the article writers frustration. He liked a thing about a product he uses and they changed the product. He is feeling angry and he is expressing that anger and others are sharing in that.

And I'm part of another group of people. I would notice the files being searched without too much interest. Since I pay a monthly rate, I don't care about optimizing tokens. I only care about the quality of the final output.

I think the larger issue is that programmers are feeling like we are losing control. At first we're like, I'll let it auto-complete but no more. Then it was, I'll let it scaffold a project but not more. Each step we are ceding ground. It is strange to watch someone finally break on "They removed the names of the files the agent was operating on". Of all of the lost points of control this one seems so trivial. But every camels back has a breaking point and we can't judge the straw that does it.

They have a dedicated product called Co-work for non-technical people. Claude Code is a *coding* tool (it's in the name) and anthropic has made decisions to thoroughly annoy a lot of the users.

If you're paying a monthly rate you still have to optimize for tokens, otherwise you'll be rate limited.

And not just by the day! The weekly limits are the biggest mistake imaginable for maintaining user engagement on a project.

[deleted]

> Seemed to work out for them overall.

I'm guessing you're not aware of how their newest game, Starfield, was received. In the long term, that direction did not work out for them at all.

Skyrim is one of the most over-rated games of all time. Dark Messiah Might and Magic did everything except music and exploration/scale better, and I mean a LOT better. It's from 2006.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-p3zj0YKKYE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeRUHzYJwNE

> Skyrim is one of the most over-rated games of all time.

Those are fightin’ words as someone who has dumped more hours than I can count into Skyrim but…

I had never heard of this game, but it has a lot going for it (source engine) and I watched a little of the gameplay you linked and I’m intrigued. I’m probably gonna pick this up for the steam deck.

A friend recommended the Might and Magic games to me a long time ago and I bought them off GoG, but wasn’t a fan of the gameplay and just couldn’t get hooked. This looks very different from what I remember (probably because this is a very different game from the earlier ones).

Thank you for mentioning this game!