But that only demonstrates that it is addictive and everyone knows it. It's the exact kind of website that this New York state law is targeting.

It just seems like hn is very open about acknowledging that. They'll still very much be subject to the state law

That's a good point.

Would you personally be in favor of HN being regulated though? I'm not sure if I would.

Indie soda makers still have to print their ingredients on the can.

So yes, I think HN should still have to acknowledge that the website is addictive in accordance with this state law.