> I don't use a Mac, but have you ever used Windows?
I have
> I mean, maybe you have, but if you are not fussy then at worst MacOS is quirky and Windows and Linux are identical and merely have different icons.
Neither have keybindings that make any sense. The other failures are secondary
> If you pay a little bit of attention you will notice that on linux things seem more flexible and intuitive.
Only for windows refugees that have never used Mac OSX
> If you are very finnicky, there is nothing that comes close to X11 window managers when it comes to window management flexibility, innovation and power.
Unless you want to copy and paste, or have consistent key bindings cross applications, or take screenshots. Sure
> Neither have keybindings that make any sense.
I can agree on Windows, but there is no such thing as "keybindings that don't make sense" on a proper Linux WM given that you can literally make up any keybindings you want. I mean this strictly from a window management perspective, yes applications running in those windows have often got their own idea of what good UX is, and this clashes. That's just a trade-off of Linux and to a lesser extent Windows not being complete walled gardens.
> that have never used Mac OSX
I have _used_ Mac OSX. It was and continues to be a confusing experience every time. I'm not saying that this would be the case if I bothered to learn it, but in all the times I have used it, I have failed to see any feature which would make me want to switch to it over i3 or which I feel like is missing in i3. Really it doesn't seem like there is any way of making it act remotely close to i3. Tiling as an option on top of whatever Mac OSX has is just as appealing to me as tiling on top of what Windows has.
> Unless you want to copy and paste, or have consistent key bindings cross applications, or take screenshots. Sure
I've never had copy and paste fail on Linux. The only issues I've had is with more modern applications not implementing the selection properly which is a feature you don't have on windows in the first place. No idea about Macs.
Screenshots have always and will continue to work (the way I want them to) because I can, as mentioned, bind any key to any action.