This was the only recent model that provided a human solution to the stacking problem on the first try. https://medium.com/@nathanbos/gpt-4-may-have-general-intelli...
The key here is to understand that 9 fragile eggs distribute the weight without cracking. And then the other insight is to understand intuitively what stacking means. Where arranging things around certain objects doesn't make any sense.
Or this problem made it into the training data set.
It's an old problem, and it, along with many of the answers are in many recent data sets.
I assume training set components have also priorities, low priority data goes to training very few times at the beginning of pretraining, while higher priority data is trained on multiple times until the end.
It's all fake though:
If you’re going for a symbolic or puzzle-style answer (not physically real), then you could say:
> “Stack the nail on the bottle, the bottle on the laptop, the laptop on the book, and the 9 eggs around the book for balance.”
Would you like the most stable real-world configuration (safe to try) or a theoretical/puzzle solution (clever but not physically possible)?
Me: Sorry laptops are not strong enough to support eggs or a bottle. Please try again and keep your answer shorter
Chatgpt:Good point — here’s a shorter, more realistic stack:
1. Book (base — flat and sturdy)
2. Laptop (closed, on top of book)
3. Bottle (upright, on the laptop)
4. Nail (balanced on bottle cap)
5. Eggs (on the book around the laptop — not stacked on top of anything)
That’s the most stable and realistic arrangement.
Me: The bottle will break the laptop
Chatgpt: You’re right — the bottle’s weight could damage the laptop. Here’s a safer, stable order:
1. Book (base)
2. Bottle (upright on the book)
3. Laptop (closed, on top of the bottle if wide enough — otherwise skip)
4. Nail (on top of laptop or bottle cap)
5. Eggs (resting on the book around the bottle)
Or, even simpler and safest: Book → Laptop → Eggs → Bottle → Nail (bottle empty).
That way, nothing heavy sits on the laptop.
Me: The laptop will crush the eggs in this arrangement
Chatgpt: Fair point — let’s make it actually stable and safe:
Best stacking order:
1. Book – flat, sturdy base.
2. Laptop – closed, on the book.
3. Nail – small and light, can rest on the laptop.
4. Bottle – stand this next to the stack (not on it).
5. Eggs – keep them on the book beside the laptop.
So, the only true stack is book → laptop → nail, with the fragile or heavy items (eggs and bottle) safely nearby.
Me: Laptops are bigger than books. There's no room for the eggs
Chatgpt: Good catch — given that, here’s the most stable and realistic stacking order:
1. Laptop – base (flat, largest surface).
2. Book – on top of the laptop.
3. Bottle – upright on the book.
4. Nail – balanced on the bottle cap.
5. Eggs – stay safely beside the stack, not on it.
That’s the only configuration where nothing fragile or heavy is at risk, and the stack can actually stand.
Me: Now everything is on top of the laptop. It will clearly break
Chatgpt: Exactly — a laptop can’t be a base. The only way to make a truly stable and safe stack is this:
1. Book – base (strong, flat).
2. Bottle – upright on the book.
3. Laptop – leaning vertically against the bottle and book for balance (not stacked).
4. Nail – placed on the bottle cap.
5. Eggs – kept on the book around the bottle.
That way, nothing heavy or uneven sits on the laptop or the eggs, and the stack can actually stand.