new | ask | show | jobs
elric 3 days ago  [ - ]

Or firejail. Or QubesOS using a dedicated VM. There are options, but it would still be nice if Obsidian had a more robust security model.

johnisgood 3 days ago  [ - ]

I have been using firejail for most of these kind of applications, be it Obsidian, Discord, or the browser I am using. I definitely recommend people start using it.

dotancohen 3 days ago  [ - ]

Sell it to us! Why do you use specifically firejail?

There are so many options, from so many different security perspectives, that analysis paralysis is a real issue.

johnisgood 3 days ago  [ - ]

I feel like I should keep track of all my comments on HN because I remember writing a lengthy comment on firejail more than once. I cannot keep doing this. :D

For user-space, there is usually bubblewrap vs. firejail. I have not personally used bubblewrap, so I cannot comment on that, but firejail is great at what it does.

The last comment was about restricting clipboard access to either X11 or Wayland which is possible with firejail quite easily, so if you want that, you can have that.

You can do a LOT more with firejail though.

https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/Firejail

https://man.archlinux.org/man/firejail.1

lioeters 2 days ago  [ - ]

> bubblewrap vs. firejail

In case anyone else is curious, I found the following comparison in bubblewrap's repo.

- https://github.com/containers/bubblewrap#related-project-com...

I'm gonna try both and see which one I like. Thanks for this info! You're sure living up to your user name there. (:

rufugee 2 days ago  [ - ]

So do you configure firejail to give each app their own separate, permanent home directories? Like "firejail --private=/home/user/firejails/discord discord", "firejail --private=/home/user/firejails/chromium chromium", and so on?

johnisgood 2 days ago  [ - ]

I have my own Discord.profile!

This is my ~/.config/firejail/Discord.profile[1]:

  include disable-common.inc
  include disable-devel.inc
  include disable-interpreters.inc
  include disable-shell.inc

  noblacklist /sys/fs
  noblacklist /sys/module

  keep-config-pulse
  keep-dev-shm

  name discord
  apparmor
  caps.drop all
  caps.keep sys_admin,sys_chroot
  netfilter
  nodvd
  #nogroups
  #noinput
  nonewprivs
  noroot
  notv
  #nou2f
  #novideo
  protocol unix,inet,inet6
  #shell none

  disable-mnt
  private-cache
  #private-tmp

  noexec /tmp

  dbus-user filter
  dbus-user.talk org.freedesktop.Notifications

  private-bin Discord,cut,echo,egrep,electron,electron[0-9],electron[0-9][0-9],grep,head,sed,sh,tr,xdg-mime,xdg-open,zsh,gzip,wget,curl,notify-send
  private-etc alternatives,asound.conf,ca-certificates,crypto-policies,fonts,group,ld.so.cache,ld.so.preload,localtime,login.defs,machine-id,password,pki,pulse,resolv.conf,ssl

  noblacklist /usr/lib/discord/
  whitelist ${HOME}/.config/discord
  read-write ${HOME}/.config/discord
  whitelist ${DOWNLOADS}
  whitelist ${HOME}/.config/pulse/*

  include whitelist-common.inc
  include whitelist-var-common.inc
  include whitelist-run-common.inc
  include whitelist-runuser-common.inc
I have some things commented out but you could probably uncomment most.

Some has this, too:

  disable-mnt
  private-dev
  private-cache

  env http_proxy=socks5://127.0.0.1:9050
  env https_proxy=socks5://127.0.0.1:9050
FWIW, once you start whitelisting, it will only have access to those directories and files only, so Discord has no access to anything other than its own directory and ${DOWNLOADS}, which I should probably change.

You should check out the default profiles for many programs / apps under directory "/etc/firejail".

[1] You run it via "firejail Discord" or "firejail ./Discord" if you name it "Discord.profile".

rufugee 2 days ago  [ - ]

This is great. Thanks for the detailed reply!

johnisgood 6 hours ago  [ - ]

It was not THAT detailed and it makes me feel a bit guilty, so if you have any questions let me know.

wonger_ 2 days ago  [ - ]

FYI you can search your comment history with hn.algolia.com:

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

johnisgood 2 days ago  [ - ]

Thank you, exactly what I have been looking for!