I suspect much of the attacks against property taxes aren't to right any historical wrongs, but is part of the attack against public education, since property taxes are a major source of funding.

No. It’s the idea that you’re renting your paid off home from the government. And the government gets to decide what it’s worth.

No, you're renting the physical space -- a scarce part of the commons -- from your community.

(I do think property taxes should be a land-value tax and not include improvements you've built.)

> No, you're renting the physical space -- a scarce part of the commons -- from your community.

Property law in the US and most western democracies doesn’t remotely agree with that. Land is not a communal or solely government owned resource, and the govt doesn’t ‘rent’ it out.

Stop paying your property taxes in the US and see how long it takes before the government forecloses. It is effectively rent under a different name. In exchange the government will protect your property ownership rights so that you don't go on vacation and find someone else now gets to claim your home since you weren't there to stop them.

Note: I think this is a good thing and that property taxes are vital to our local communities well-being.