I read the article and I feel like I don't understand what was being contested. One lawyer says "yes thing" and the other says "no thing."

What, precisely, is thing? I'm not a lawyer.

Anyway, yeah we know when women are menstruating now so let's cash out. What was the issue, though? Is the idea "I use this to track my own schedule, not to be sold out to strangers"?

Because, I'm sorry, but whether it's menstruation, palpation, or childbirth, if you put it in an app then the whole point was to sell you out.

Good that class action is questioning this, but I wonder how much is law and how much is posturing feels.