"Lithium propulsion for aircraft and boats is fundamentally unprofitable (..)"

It's annoying (and ignorant) author lumps aircraft & boats into 1 category.

Jumbo jets won't be electrified anytime soon. Weight (and thus, energy density/kg) is everything. But synthetic fuels, hydrogen etc might be good options.

But there's also short-haul flights. Routes with say, 15..20min between take-off & landing. For such flights, electric aircraft is entirely feasible. And being done (successfully) in some places. Not to mention eg. training aircraft.

Boats: veeerry different. Weight isn't a biggie, neither is volume. And there's short-haul ferries, long(er)-haul ferries, cruise ships, 10000+ container giants, tug boats, recreational boats that hardly ever leave lakes/canals/rivers, sailboats with engine that's mostly used while entering/leaving port but not out @ sea, etc etc.

Each of these have their own economics. Where they're used and (energy) infrastructure there, is also a factor. Container giant on Asia-Europe route? Good luck electrifying that. Small tourist boat doing 20..30km/day in a natural park? Electric is a no-brainer, today.

And there's existing vessels vs. newly built ones. Most boats get old (like aircraft), more so than cars. Retrofits can be difficult/expensive. But for yet-to-build boats, different story.

Lumping that all in 1 aircraft/boat category, and claiming "uneconomical!" is just dumb.

> Jumbo jets won't be electrified anytime soon. Weight (and thus, energy density/kg) is everything. But synthetic fuels, hydrogen etc might be good options.

That's making me think that hydrogen-filled airships (Zeppelins/dirigibles) might be practical with some kind of electric propulsion. That way, the weight is no longer so much of an issue, though the trade-off is that they'll need to be bigger. Their speed (or slowness) could be an advantage in that they should be much easier to fly and collisions would hopefully be infrequent and not so catastrophic (I'm picturing more of a bounce than a collision).

Clearly the whole article is wasting hundreds if not thousands of peoples time.